Showing posts with label Thar coal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thar coal. Show all posts

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Thar Coal update

Thar Coal: some submissions

Our energy crisis is so huge and worsening that one finds it only appropriate to belabor the known facts and bring forward new thoughts and solutions that come to ones mind. By this time, it should have become obvious that there is no escape from fast tracking the Thar coal project. Hydro power is also an equally viable option which solves water storage problem also , but suffers from seasonal factors . The two resources together offer optimal opportunities to meet Pakistan’s Energy demands. Here we are focusing on Thar coal.

The bureaucratic circles tend to show that there is progress on Thar coal. But the fact remains, that there is almost none. Allocation of blocks, MOUs and even feasibility studies do not mean much, as many such things have been done in the past. Under-ground coal gasification project has raised false hopes among the public. Without casting doubts on the scientific credentials of its eminent promoters and on the technological potential of the route adopted, the problem of scaling up would remain for which there is no capability in the country of a level that would be acceptable to the lending banks. While the existing gasification would yield useful data, we would be back to the square one, which is of requisite financing.

The bad news is that under criticism and pressure from international Green lobbies, World Bank has discontinued its technical assistance program on Thar coal, amidst news that government of Sindh has persuaded them to renew it. Even if they do renew, it sends us ample signals on difficulties that we are going to face towards financing Thar coal. With time, the opposition to coal would increase. Our problem is immediate and the renewables are still to be perfected and improved to be cost effective and competitive. In any case, renewables are projected to have a share of 20% even by the year 2050 .What are we to do in the meantime. The threat is that by the time we put our act together, although fossil based power age may not be over, the financing regime may become too difficult and hostile against coal.

The residual issue as it stands today is not the financing issue of the mining and power parts of the projects, however difficult it may itself be, it is the financing of infrastructure part which is proving to be a stumbling block. Various estimates put these requirements to between 1 to 2 billion US dollars. More money is required for infrastructure, than the first coal mine and power plant itself .Government of Sindh, obviously would not have such resources, nor would the federal government. And in these days of emphasis on provincial autonomy, where is the appetite for common projects. There are also issues as to the technical and management capability of the provincial bureaucracy, as the project continues to be run from the narrow confines of the Sindh secretariat. Apparently, there is no shaft of light at the end of this tunnel, although it is not the only one.

In all humbleness, this scribe makes the following proposals. There are two options. One is to tender for a large project of 5000 MW or so, which may be able to assume the infrastructural development costs. The cake becomes big enough to absorb all kinds of interests. This is not new .In India, this size of coal projects are being planned already. The feasibility of this proposal in Pakistan context can only be tested once it is actually tendered. The second option would be to float tenders for establishing a mining development company that undertakes to develop and finance the infrastructure and manages the Thar coal operations on behalf of Sindh government, within the framework of the relevant rules and regulations. The company recoups its investments by granting mining leases and charging a fee on coal production by individual companies. Obviously such a company would be a multinational which may have a joint venture with local private sector and government of Sindh’s share in it. Such a company would offer many advantages. First of all to bring in finances, which appear to be well-nigh impossible for Sindh government to finance? Secondly, the operations would be more commercial like and would be on fast track. Ironically, I have made a case of yet another feasibility study? Not necessarily.

Certain issues related to the 18th Amendment need to be sorted out. After the amendment, Electricity sector becomes a federal only subject, as there is no concurrent list any more. Earlier Electricity was in concurrent list. Coal was and is a provincial subject. If I understand correctly, federal responsibility and role in Electrical power sector should be larger than it was prior to the amendment. Thar coal power development , therefore, ought to occupy higher priority in Federal budgeting system. It may not be a bad idea considering some kind of linkage between investments in Hydro and Thar coal power; one project in hydel, and one in Thar coal. There is a technical requirement to balance hydel power as well. Gas being no more and oil unaffordably expensive and imported, thermal energy in future should mean Thar coal energy. Politicians from Sindh can suitably make a convincing case, provided they are also prepared to readily agree to federal involvement.

Let me close with good news, if at all. Some politicians lately made a statement that Thar coal is larger than the oil resources of our rich brothers of the Middle East. Many people cast a doubt on such an assertion. This scribe has collected facts and data and has made some calculations and is happy to report that these claims are by far correct with the following details and provisos. Total Middle East Oil and gas resources add up to equivalent of 385 billion tons of Brown coal, out of which Iran and Saudi Arabia own 110 billion tons of coal equivalent each. Pakistan’s Thar coal is 185 billion tons. We should, however, remember that Saudis would have been quite poor had they had 189 million people to support, instead of their current population of 25 million only.

The writer is a former Harvard University fellow, and has authored the book “ Pakistan’s Energy Development; the road ahead”,

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Should Coal be imported,inspite of Thar Coal ?

Should Coal be Imported , inspite of Thar Coal ?

Coal is being imported in Pakistan and the imports are increasing every year. Coal is required and used in industries such as cement, brick kiln, metallurgical industries etc.

Hard coal of good quality is also being mined in Balochistan, KP and Punjab. Production of hard coal is limited by manual and artisanal mining. The known sources are not large enough to attract capital and mechanization. Whatever is produced is consumed, and even imports are made to meet the demand.

In this section, we are concerned with a specific question. Should we import coal for power sector? There is advantage in coal. In Pakistan , there are large deposits of Thar coal, and in the world coal is the most abundant fuel, expected to afford 200 years of world consumption. It is abundant in China, US, Australia, India, Canada, and India and the lesser countries of Indonesia and South Africa. Industrial revolution in Europe took place on the shoulders of the then abundant coal there. Coal served as a backbone to progress and production in almost every industrial society.

Coal is being much despised and opposed these days by the generally environmentally sensitive world of today. Pollution and Green-house gases are the two principal factors responsible for the opposition and resistance against coal. On the other hand, this is also true that most electricity in the world today comes from coal. In the U.S., almost 50% of electricity comes from coal. In China, one Coal Power plant goes up every week. India has an installed base of MW of coal power and a sizeable coal resource base. However, it has started importing coal for a variety of reasons; principal among those is excess demand due to production bottlenecks, despite a sizable resource base. In the U.S. all kind of energy is produced, imported and exported.

Why import, when one is exporting; and why export when one is importing. Trade is done for many reasons seasonal factors, location issues, transportation costs, business linkage etc. In the case of coal, imported coal may be cheaper than domestically produced due to shear logistics reasons. Coastal towns and markets may prefer imported coal for convenience and cost reasons , if domestically produced coal is far off in the inner regions. That is the reason behind energy trade in the U.S., involving imports and exports as well. In Pakistan , despite cotton abundance , it is considered wise to keep imports open to have a check on the local prices , as well as seasonal issues. Excess supply and availability in certain months may induce exports and lesser availability in others may induce imports. India, to-date prefers importing coal for coastal towns, as imports are cheaper in coastal towns due to cheaper transportation than bringing domestic coal from inner regions. At some point in time, India may import Thar coal or electricity produced from it, for its coal scarce regions of Rajhastan and Gujrat, which are adjoining Pakistan, in place of coal from south .It is shear economics, if politics permit it to operate. Often it does not. Similarly, Pakistan may import Coal from Afghanistan, in preference to its own coal in the South.

Am I making a case for importing coal for establishing power plants, as some foreign companies have proposed? Why have they done so? For almost the same reasons as we have discussed earlier. However, the primary concern is that people are generally skeptical if Thar coal resource would come on line at all? Our provincial government of Sindh and its relevant departments may not like this kind of skepticism. Every now and then they do announce their actions, projects and approvals. Engro has completed its feasibility study, which gives some credibility and optimism. However, it is still a low key affair, not befitting of a gigantic project of this nature, being largely operated and handled from a single room in Sindh Secretariat. Visibility and profile gives credibility to vendors, technology suppliers, investors etc. Unfortunately, its absence does not appear to be very reassuring. If projects are progressing, these are to be planned, monitored and co-ordinated .It requires qualified managers and manpower, training activity etc. No credible international party is yet on board. The sole public demonstration of such an association is indicted by a trip to Germany by the project authorities. World Bank is double minded, despite its technical and financial assistance project. Some very fundamental issues which may impede progress ultimately are of coal pricing and royalty. These remain unstudied and unresolved. To federal bureaucracy, the provincial set-up appears to be too tight lipped and secretive , resisting involvement of others which may be a requirement of such a huge projects. Some of them are looking forward to the ultimate failure of the provincial government and its relevant department, which appears to be the sole player trying to take it to the goal all alone. Chinese , the most befitting partners , for Thar coal do not appear to be interested at all in it , while they are interested in every thing else from nuclear power plants to dams etc. There is something missing?

However, I do not think that going for the imported coal option for new power plants would be a good idea at all. First and foremost, such a project would crowd out the investment in domestic coal, after there is a limited supply of foreign capital willing to come to Pakistan esp in the difficult political circumstances. Coal prices also increase in sympathy with oil, as has been amply demonstrated by the recent past. We are suffering from a perennial trade gap and balance of payment problems obliging us to approach IMF for loans restricting policy options for economic expansion and peoples’ welfare. Import of coal would be a luxury we cannot possibly afford. In South, we already have Thar coal. Had there been some possibilities of sourcing the same from hypothetical northern sources, there would have been a logistical rationale for meeting the requirements of the upper and central regions. In these circumstances, there appears to be no rationale for entertaining such projects, except slow progress on Thar, which it is hoped, would be speeded up by a co-ordinated action of Federal and provincial governments.